Last Day to Place Holiday Orders

Make your holiday easy and delicious by ordering pies, desserts, and dessert platters from Barstow’s Dairy Store and Bakery. Holiday dessert orders must be in by Monday, December 20 before 3pm, – but it is never too early to place your order!

Visit us or call us at 413-586-2142 to reserve your holiday desserts. Please let us know your complete order with all the details, the name of who is picking up the order, pick up date and time, phone number, any special instructions, and if anyone in your party has a food allergy. Orders over $25 must be held with a credit card or paid in advance of pick up.

Here are some of our most popular dessert orders for the holidays! Don’t see what you want? Just ask!

Barstow’s Homemade Pies:
apple, apple crumb, chocolate cream, pumpkin, peanut butter dream, blueberry, cherry, pecan, chocolate pecan, coconut cream, banana cream, lemon meringue, minced meat – view pies and pricing

Barstow’s Homemade Cheesecake:
plain, double chocolate, pumpkin swirl, Bailey’s, cow spots, chocolate peanut butter, chocolate butterscotch, NY style with cherry, blueberry, strawberry, or apple crisp, coconut, cinnamon bun, cookie dough, turtle, or a custom cheesecake – view cheesecakes and pricing

Other Barstow’s Favorites:
custom cakes, chocolate peanut butter bars, candy cane whoopie pies, carrot cake, cinnamon swirls, danish, blueberry muffins, mini pastry platter, holiday mini dessert platters, and more!

Any orders placed after Monday, December 20 at 3pm will need baker approval (please note that we not able to accept ANY additional orders after Thanksgiving this year, so early is best!). Get a jump on things! And hey, if you don’t, we’ll have a few extras available on Christmas Eve too…