Thanksgiving is a time for family and for excellent food! Barstow’s Dairy Store and Bakery offers custom baked goods, pies, cakes, cheesecakes, and prepared foods for the holiday season.
Thanksgiving orders are due by Friday, November 18 by 4pm.
All orders placed after that time will need baker approval, we may not be able to honor late orders.
So don’t wait! Call us at 413-586-2142 or stop by to place your Thanksgiving order! For simple orders, we are accepting online pre-orders here, through Wed. Nov. 16.
Pick up is also a breeze! Pick up on the day ahead that works best for you. We’ll be open until 6pm on Wednesday, November 23, the day before Thanksgiving.
Pies
Apple Pie… 17.00
Apple Crumb Pie… 17.00
Banana Cream Pie… 16.00
Blueberry Pie… 20.00
Cherry Pie… 16.00
Chocolate Cream Pie… 17.00
Chocolate Pecan Pie… 20.50
Coconut Cream Pie… 16.00
Key Lime Pie… 17.00
Lemon Meringue… 19.00
Minced Meat… 17.00
Mixed Berry… 19.00
Pecan Pie… 20.00
Peanut Butter Dream… 19.00
Pumpkin Pie… 17.00
Cheesecake
Plain… 42.00
Chocolate Chip… 42.00
Double Chocolate42.00
Pumpkin… 42.00
Choc Peanut Butter… 42.00
Choc Butterscotch… 42.00
NY Style w/ Cherry… 45.00
NY Style w/ Blueberry… 45.00
NY Style w/ Strawberry… 45.00
Apple Crisp… 45.00
Peach Crisp… 45.00
Coconut… 45.00
Cinnamon Bun… 45.00
Cookie Dough… 45.00
Turtle… 45.00
Bailey’s Irish Cream… 45.00
Custom Other… tbd
Other favorites
Pan of Cinnamon Swirls… 9.90
Danish… 3.85
Scones… 3.60
Muffins… 2.75
12″ Cookie Platter… 27.00
18″ Cookie Platter… 57.50
12″ Mini Pastry Platter… 41.50
18″ Mini Pastry Platter… 60.50
12″ Mini Cheesecake Platter… 46.50
18″ Mini Cheesecake Platter… 84.50
12″ Assorted Mini Dessert Platter… 55.50
18″ Assorted Mini Dessert Platter… 70.50
Find our full offerings on our Bakery Page HERE or on our Catering Page HERE. Online orders for pies and cheesecakes only may be placed here (payment required at pick up). Questions? 413-387-9108